Tax-Deferred Annuities
How tax-deferred growth can compound over time.
A tax-deferred annuity allows eligible earnings inside the contract to grow without being subject to federal income tax each year. Instead, taxes are generally deferred until money is withdrawn, subject to applicable tax rules.
At Money Man 4 Integrity, we believe understanding the tax treatment of an annuity is just as important as understanding its interest rate, guarantees, fees, liquidity provisions, and contract terms.
FREE TO EXPLORE — NO OBLIGATION — MONEY MAN 4 INTEGRITY
The tax-deferral concept
Earnings
Deferred
Compounding
Tax deferral is one feature of an annuity—not the entire investment decision.
What Is a Tax-Deferred Annuity?
Understanding tax deferral, retirement savings, and annuity options
A tax-deferred annuity is an insurance contract that can allow earnings to grow without current federal income taxation until they are withdrawn, subject to applicable tax rules.
Fixed Deferred
Fixed Deferred Annuity
A fixed deferred annuity generally provides a stated interest rate or other contractual interest-crediting provisions while allowing earnings to grow tax deferred. A MYGA is one example.
Indexed
Fixed Indexed Annuity
A fixed indexed annuity may credit interest based in part on a selected market index. The amount credited depends on the contract's specific crediting method.
Market-Based
Variable Annuity
A variable annuity generally provides investment options whose values can fluctuate based on the performance of underlying investments.
The common feature is that taxes on applicable earnings are generally deferred until withdrawal.
The Mechanics
How tax deferral can compound over time
When taxes aren't reducing applicable earnings each year, more money can remain invested and potentially compound over time.
Start With Your Savings
Consider two hypothetical investors who each have $100,000 of after-tax savings available for retirement.
Compare Taxable Treatment
A taxable investment account may create annual tax liabilities depending on the type of income or gains generated.
Allow Applicable Earnings to Stay Invested
Inside a tax-deferred annuity, eligible earnings generally remain in the contract without current federal income taxation until withdrawn.
Consider the Long-Term Effect
More money remaining invested can potentially compound over time.
Illustrative example
Important
This example illustrates the potential impact of tax deferral. It does not mean a tax-deferred annuity is automatically better than a taxable investment account.
Where the Money Comes From
Qualified vs. non-qualified tax-deferred annuities
The distinction matters because the tax treatment of contributions and withdrawals can differ.
Qualified
Funded With Pre-Tax Retirement Assets
A qualified annuity is generally funded with assets from a tax-advantaged retirement account or arrangement.
- Traditional IRAs
- 401(k) plans
- Other eligible employer retirement plans
Distributions are generally subject to applicable income-tax rules, and required minimum distribution rules may apply depending on the account and circumstances.
Non-Qualified
Funded With After-Tax Savings
A non-qualified annuity is generally funded with money that has already been subject to income taxation.
- Savings
- Brokerage accounts
- Inheritance
- Other after-tax assets
The original premium generally isn't taxed again when returned, while applicable earnings withdrawn are generally subject to ordinary income tax.
Tax-Deferred vs. Roth vs. 401(k)
Where does a tax-deferred annuity fit?
A tax-deferred annuity can be one component of a broader retirement strategy.
Roth IRA
A Roth IRA can provide tax-free qualified withdrawals, subject to applicable requirements. It has different contribution limits and eligibility rules.
Traditional IRA & 401(k)
Traditional retirement accounts generally provide tax-advantaged treatment, but withdrawals are generally taxable under applicable rules. Simply moving retirement money into an annuity doesn't automatically create additional tax advantages.
Non-Qualified Annuity
A non-qualified annuity can provide tax-deferred growth outside traditional retirement accounts, but tax benefits should be weighed against surrender charges, fees, ordinary-income taxation of gains, and other contract considerations.
Before purchasing a non-qualified annuity, consider whether you have already taken advantage of other retirement savings opportunities available to you.
The Potential Benefits
Why tax deferral can be valuable
Compounding
Growth Can Compound Without Annual Taxation
Applicable earnings can remain inside the annuity without being reduced by current federal income taxes each year, allowing more money to remain invested.
Guarantees
Fixed Deferred Annuities Can Provide Contractual Guarantees
Certain fixed deferred annuities may provide guarantees regarding interest crediting or principal, subject to the contract and the insurer's claims-paying ability.
Contributions
Non-Qualified Annuities Generally Have No Annual IRS Contribution Limit
Unlike IRAs and many employer-sponsored retirement accounts, non-qualified annuities generally do not have the same annual IRS contribution limits, although insurers can impose their own limitations.
Withdrawal Timing
Depending on the contract, you can generally decide when to begin taking withdrawals and may allow the account to accumulate for years.
Lifetime Income
Some annuities can be converted into lifetime income according to the contract.
Product Flexibility
Different annuity types provide different interest-crediting, investment, income, and guarantee structures.
The Potential Drawbacks
Understand the limitations before purchasing
Tax & Access Considerations
- Withdrawals before age 59½ may trigger a 10% additional federal tax unless an exception applies.
- Taxable annuity gains are generally taxed as ordinary income rather than long-term capital gains.
- Surrender charges can limit early access.
Estate & Investment Considerations
- Annuities don't automatically receive a step-up in basis.
- Beneficiaries may receive taxable deferred gains depending on the circumstances.
- Fees, liquidity, investment alternatives, and contract features should all be reviewed.
The Surrender Period Trap
Why the first several years matter
A surrender schedule determines how long certain withdrawals may be subject to surrender charges.
Why This Matters
- A strong interest rate doesn't make an annuity appropriate if you need the money before liquidity restrictions expire.
- Unexpected cash needs during the surrender period can result in surrender charges.
- Don't put money into a fixed deferred annuity that you may need for near-term expenses.
When Not to Use One
When a tax-deferred annuity may not be the right tool
A tax-deferred annuity isn't automatically appropriate for everyone.
01
You May Need the Money Before Age 59½
Early withdrawals may trigger additional federal tax penalties unless an exception applies.
02
You Haven't Used Other Retirement Savings Opportunities
Employer contributions, matches, IRAs, and other tax-advantaged accounts may deserve consideration first.
03
You Expect a Significantly Lower Tax Rate Later
Tax deferral can be more attractive when the tax rate at withdrawal is favorable relative to your current situation, although future tax rates are uncertain.
04
You're Investing Primarily for Heirs
Compare annuity tax treatment with other investment and estate-planning options when legacy planning is the primary goal.
05
You Need Maximum Liquidity
Surrender periods and contract restrictions may make a fixed deferred annuity less suitable if you want unrestricted access to savings.
Tax-Deferred Annuities vs. Other Options
Consider the complete picture
Before purchasing a tax-deferred annuity, compare it with alternatives.
Taxable Brokerage Account
A brokerage account can provide significant liquidity and investment flexibility, but taxable earnings may create annual tax liabilities.
Roth IRA
Qualified Roth IRA withdrawals can be tax-free under applicable rules, making a Roth account an important comparison when eligible.
Traditional IRA
Traditional IRAs provide tax-advantaged retirement savings, subject to applicable contribution and distribution rules.
401(k)
Employer-sponsored retirement plans may provide tax advantages, employer matching, and other benefits.
The right combination depends on your individual financial circumstances.
Common Questions
Tax-Deferred Annuity FAQ
How does a tax-deferred annuity differ from a 401(k) or IRA?
Is a tax-deferred annuity better than a Roth IRA?
What is a fixed deferred annuity?
How is a fixed deferred annuity different from a variable annuity?
Can I move money out of a tax-deferred annuity without paying taxes?
What happens to a tax-deferred annuity when I die?
Ready to Explore Tax-Deferred Annuities?
See whether tax-deferred growth fits your retirement strategy.
Tax deferral can be a valuable feature, but it shouldn't be the only reason you purchase an annuity.
FREE TO EXPLORE — NO OBLIGATION